Do you think it is fair? The government feels that requiring a minimum standard of noise on electric hybrid automobiles is essential to ensure the safety of all pedestrians where pedestrians and vehicles come in close proximity with one another?
Some in favor of “less government” feel they can add this to the list of government interference with personal owner’s responsibility. Although the cars are very quiet (their engines are silent in comparison with those of gasoline-powered cars), some express the strong opinion that it is the driver’s duty to ensure they are alert and aware of what is around them. This means eliminating the use of cell phones and other distractions. Drivers need to make their safety and the safety of others there top priority.
Others though, feel that a law will help ensure the sfaety of all for those moments when either driver or pedestrian are not fully aware of one another. For example, a blind mother carrying a child in a carrier will not pick up on the visual cues of seeing the car. She can not assume that the drivers will always be aware of her. If the electric car has a minimum sound standard, she will be able to utilize the noise to make personal judgement-calls to keep her and her child safe.
Still others agree that the “quiet” electric cars pose a challenge for pedestrians, but feel that added “noise-makers” on these cars, is not a satisfactory solution. They fear that the sounds will just blend in with other typical traffic noises. They also wonder if the noises will eventually be ignored due to commonality. They feel that maybe what will start out as a good intention may end up causing problems and may not solve anything after all.
Is it fair for the government to ensure personal safety or is that each individual’s responsibility? Will added noise to electric cars be helpful or not really fix the problem?









